The Tucson Gardener

Leaf lettuce.
Bed of winter leaf lettuce.

 Current Cultivations

Garden Clubs

Garden Books

In the Garden Calendar

Tucson's Wildlife

Ruby Swiss chard.
Ruby Swiss chard.

Local Garden Links

Links for Special Needs

The Archive

The Tool Shed

Snow peas.
Snow peas ready for harvest.

FAQ

Glossary

Search

Site Index


You're visiting Tucsongardener.com

 

Nursery Survey
It was  Thursday, October 22, 1998 when I set out on a quest for knowledge. Under a cloudy sky, the temperature about 68 degrees and a blowing wind, I'd become curious if I shopped in the right places when I bought plants for my garden. (I visited the Oracle Road Home Depot on Friday morning, October 23.) My first criteria for buying plants has always been convenience - no sense driving across town if I don't have to. Save gas, save time and conserve energy for gardening. I also never shop on weekends because I don't like to stand in line when it comes time to pay the bill. And my little expedition on Thursday showed that nurseries and garden centers were stocking up for the weekend ahead.

By visiting a Home Depot garden center on a weekend one gets the impression price, especially for bedding plants, is the most important thing when it comes to buying plants. The growers drive fresh plants in by the truck loads and stock the tables weeding out anything that's become spindly or missed getting watered once to often.  A wilted or ugly plant is an unsold plant. All The Home Depot employees have to do is keep the plants watered and ring up the sales at the cash register. Of course the Depot is also selling a lot of other products related to home and garden.  So why shop any where else? That's like asking why eat anything but fast food?

Chances are a good quality nursery will have a wider selection when it comes to plant materials and they may grow many of their own plants so they're well suited for Tucson's climate. But more important is the service and knowledgeable people selling the plants.  They can answer your questions and make suggestions for your growing needs.

I dropped into a local nursery in mid September on a Monday morning. I went with the intention of buying a 15 gallon mesquite tree, some bedding plants and other miscellaneous gardening necessities. The nursery wasn't busy. In fact I was the only customer there. I browsed and checked out the quality of the plants and waited patiently for someone to come and offer "service". It didn't happen. Needless to say I drove on down the road to another nursery where I bought my plants, saved some money and got the service I deserved. I doubt I'll return to the nursery that didn't offer much help on that Monday morning because there are too many other places to shop in Tucson.

Another example is the time I wanted 25 bags of composted steer manure but couldn't get the help I wanted loading it into my truck. I went elsewhere. Admittedly I paid more per bag but I got it loaded into the truck and saved a little wear and tear on my back. So my basic criteria for shopping for garden plants and related items is

  1. Location - I don't want to drive across Tucson to get my plants if I can get the same quality or better closer to home.

  2. Plant selection - I want the nursery or garden center to have what I'm looking for along with plants I don't know about.

  3. Plant quality - I want to start with healthy, attractive  plants.

  4. Friendly and knowledgeable personnel - I expect the people working in the nursery to be willing to talk gardening and know what they're talking about.

  5. Price - I like the prices to be visible, and if they're on sale, I want that price to be obvious and not hidden on some advertisement posted on the front door.

My nursery survey is brief and not very scientific. I started at the Star Nursery at Ina Road and I-10 and then headed east. I drove into one place on River Road but their business was mainly bedding plants to the wholesale market so it was scratched from my list.

I did go to Mesquite Valley Growers for the first time. I'd heard numerous radio advertisements for the place and have been curious. Who says advertising doesn't pay?

In the future I'll make sure that I visit more of Tucson' nurseries. (There are many and they come in all sizes and locations. Some are specialized in what they sell.)

I must admit I'm amazed by the gardening business the Home Depot on Oracle at the Rillito River does. Often it seems they're selling bedding plants none of the nurseries are carrying at the time. I watched a gardener purchase one gallon tomato plants in mid October. He got out of the building before I could catch up with him to ask him how he was going to grow those with cold weather not more than a month or so away.

I also saw a woman buying tomato plants and I did ask her. She said they were Early Girls and it would be no problem. And here I had a whole raised bed of tomato plants that I'd planted in August and I'm still questioning whether I'll get any ripe tomatoes before the first freeze kills the plants.

Keep in mind plants grow well in the controlled environment of a greenhouse. That doesn't mean they're going to do as well in the uncontrolled environment of your garden if they haven't been hardened off.

Now for a disclaimer. The prices I have listed below were taken from what was posted on the plant's container or from nearby signage. The varieties available may not be the same at every nursery.  Some of the nurseries grow their own bedding plants instead of purchasing them from a grower in Phoenix or some other location. That means they'll be more acclimated to our desert climate and should be expected to get off to a better start when planted. Peat moss brands varied between nurseries and garden centers.

Editor's note: The prices in the table below were late 1998 prices.
 

*** Rillito
Nursery
Catalina
Heights
Nursery
Mesquite Valley Growers Home Depot
15 Gallon
Chilean Mesquite tree
59.99 45.00 45.00 29.90
Not a Chilean mesquite
5 gallon Cassia 13.99 18.60-19.60 13.95 10.97
5 gallon Green Cloud 14.99

17.50

14.95 9.80
1 gallon purple trailing lantana 3.99

5.00

3.95 2.47
1-2.2 cubic foot bag sphagnum peat moss 11.99 8.30 9.99 7.68
1 pony pack petunias 2.69 Single plants grown in peat pots
.85 each
4-inch pots only .98 each 1.78
4-inch pot 1.49 .85 plant in a peat pot. .98 .78

Total Cost:

109.13 96.10 89.80 63.38

Current Cultivations  |  Garden Clubs  |  Garden Books  |  In the Garden Calendar  |  Tucson's Wildlife  |  Local Links  |  Links for Special Needs  |  The Archive  |  The Tool Shed  |  FAQ  |
 |  Glossary  |  Search  |  Site Index  |


The Tucson Gardener - Tucson's Gardening Information Site
Copyright© 1998-2008. All Rights Reserved 
Disclaimer

 No material, written or photographic, may be reprinted or used without written permission.
Contact Information.